Trouble in paradise? Just weeks after the Love Island USA season 7 reunion filmed, Iris Kendall and Jose “Pepe” Garcia-Gonzalez may have called it quits. The reality TV finalists, who became fan favorites during the summer season,

It looks like the honeymoon phase may have ended for Pepe and Iris. Get an update on their relationship and learn about the cheating rumors.

After leaving the villa and placing 4th on season 7, Pepe and Iris said they were ready to commit to each other. "We both date in very similar ways,” Pepe told PEOPLE in a joint