The actress stars alongside Pedro Pascal and Chris Evans as a woman caught between two very different men in a new film from ‘Past Lives’ director Celine Song.

Still, John is a late-30s actor-slash-cater waiter who still lives with roommates. Not to mention, they had already dated for five years and broke up over money—specifically, a lack of it. Anyone, and especially a matchmaker like Lucy, would tell you that on paper, Harry is Husband Material and that there's a reason John is an ex.