Fear Street is back with Prom Queen, but the film is way, way worse than the original trilogy with a new director and writers.

Fear Street: Prom Queen ends in carnage when Megan realizes some of the other prom queen nominees, Christy Renault (Greenblatt), Melissa (Rubin) and Debbie (Ablack) have vanished. Lori and Tiffany Falconer (Strazza), however, are still notably alive on the dance floor.

Prom Queen’ is a hollow, nostalgia-soaked slasher that stumbles through clichés, forgettable kills, and zero suspense. Even its 1988 setting and killer soundtrack can’t save it from being the franchise’s weakest link yet.